Purpose. Clemson’s VSM ToolBox and Pérez Ríos’s VSMod showed software can support Stafford Beer’s Viable System Model; however, LLMs introduce a cybernetic problem: plausible inference can harden into organisational fact and propagate across recursion levels. This project traces a path from evidence to hypotheses, questions and interventions.
Methods. The prototype ran on two public-record cases: Robin Hood Energy, and the Charity Commission inquiry into New Wineskins and U-Turn Move on Homes. It proposes operations, relations and recursive structure, promoting each only when an evidence-gated test passes, abstaining otherwise. An operation becomes a child system one level down only when at least two cited source units evidence its internal operations and boundary. Structural gaps become focused questions; answers and corrections persist through reanalysis. Hypotheses and prescriptions carry checks that could confirm or refute them. Any LLM-attributed quotation must match its cited source verbatim.
Findings. Both produced evidence-linked maps and explicit gaps. In one, an entered answer that no role monitored the external environment or future was retained verbatim as evidence of a System 4 gap; no function was invented. VSM operates as a reasoning grammar, not only a diagram.
Implications/Contributions. The contribution is an evidence-to-inquiry loop that turns abstention into diagnostic work while model suggestions remain provisional, complementing Metaphorum 2025’s work on AI-augmented VSM decision environments. Results demonstrate software traceability, not diagnostic validity or organisational impact; practitioner testing comes next. The session is a live demonstration: participants answer gap questions and see reanalysis. When should AI-proposed structure become a diagnostic premise?
Update, 6 August 2026: Robin Hood Energy was withdrawn after cold probes showed the models already knew the case’s history.